top of page

A GIRL OF THE LIMBERLOST BOOK CLUB - WEEK 6 - CHAPTERS 9-10

Writer: Sarah
Sarah
2 minutes ago
3 min read

A GIRL OF THE LIMBERLOST by Gene Stratton-Porter


So much has changed in a week for Elnora. She can hardly believe what her life looks like now, and as she approaches home, she is shocked to hear her mother laughing. Why, she must have company, and she does-Mark Twain in the form of a book. As a book lover, I loved that moment in the story. Especially since I'll be reading some Mark Twain with my lit students in a couple of months! Seriously though, do you ever come upon your child who is totally lost to the world and engrossed in a book? It's a wonderful thing to watch. It had to have brought Elnora so much joy knowing that she had provided laughter for her mother by leaving the book for her.


How lovely that Elnora is now providing nature lessons for the younger students in her school. How fun it is to read about all the things she gather and prepares.


I also loved how Elnora has made her place in with the girls at school and has not lost herself in the process. She's a part of the after school treat group, and when it's her turn to treat, she sticks to goodies from home, and boy, don't they sound wonderful?! The girls seem to love the snacks, and why wouldn't they? Sweets made by hand have the spice of care and love added in. How fun to see that even Kate and Maggie join in on the creating.


But it's the violin that we have to talk about the most from this chapter. Elnora overhears the orchestra, and she falls in love with music, especially the violin.


Now, I'm going to rabbit trail here a moment, because we have all these beautiful literary techniques that really shine in this chapter. We have personification when the violins sing and "speak a language' she understands. We have hyperbole with Kate's response when she flies off the handle at Elnora for mentioning violins and again later when Elnora claims she would die without one. We have metaphors popping out when Elnora can make the violin be "the wind in the swamp, the birds, and the animals." There really is a lot of gorgeousness that drips from these pages!


We have to ask ourselves why Kate hates the violin so much and why Maggie turns pale when Elnora mentions her love of it. We have to ask how in the world Elnora has so much natural talent to the point of picking one up and creating coherent and beautiful sounds from its strings. (Have you ever tried to play a violin? Initially, it's screech, screech, screech. There's very little that's pleasing to the ear when first playing.) The whole key to this is Elnora's father. There's a lot of mystery about what happened the night he died. For some reason, Maggie knows where Elnora's father's violin is, and that's another mystery all by itself.


Maggie goes and retrieves the violin from the person who has it, and now, Elnora has her very own to play. And play, she does! She grows and exceeds expectations. Time flies by. and it's now her senior year. Elnora has a spotlight role in the play. We knew that at some point everything was going to have to come to a head, and Kate learn about Elnora's secret passion.


There are a couple of things that really catch my attention in this chapter. First is that Elnora could go all the way through school, and her mother really have no idea what is going on in her daughter's life. Having four girls of my own, that just absolutely baffles me. Second is that while Elnora is playing (Didn't you love the personification that shows up here about the violin?), Kate ends up passing out. The men just pick her up, splash her face in the fountain, revive her, put her in her carriage, and leave her. No one checks on her, and she runs toward home. Third, and even more so, is the quote at the end of the chapter. "The swamp had sent back the soul of her loved dead and put it into the body of the daughter she resented, and it was almost more than she could bear and live." There will be a lot to unpack from that in the coming chapters.


There's a few more things from these chapters that I haven't covered, that are worthy of mentioning, but I'll leave those for anyone who wants to comment about them. I'd love to hear from you!




Sharing stories, building faith, and growing together, one book at a time.

© 2025 by Sarah's Book Reviews

  • Facebook
bottom of page